Jonathan McLatchie, Please Ask Pfander Films to Provide Evidence for this Shocking Claim

Jay Smith specifically claimed he had video evidence to back this shocking claim up. He’s being asked for that video footage now. He has made very serious claims about Muslims in Britain and specifically those at Speakers Corner.

I’ve looked for the video evidence which he claims is available on the internet. I can’t find it. All I could find is him talking about the third caliph who burnt Quranic manuscripts (I’ve added a clip of Dr Yasir Qadhi to the end of the video to explain this event)

He claimed a big crowd of Muslims said it was OK to kill random people upon seeing some Christian burn a copy of the Quran and they all threatened to kill him if he burnt a copy in London.

Posting footage of all this would be propaganda gold for him, his organisation and his friends (the David Wood types).It would go viral and get them the type of attention they clearly seek. Where is the video of this purported incident?

Jay Smith of Pfander Films has a reputation for not valuing truth and accuracy. Did he make this story up to slander Muslims to promote his missionary activities?

This is a transcript of one of Jay’s versions of the story:

Just yesterday, in fact, I was at Speaker’s Corner, and I got up there, and I don’t know if you remember what happened of Friday. Nine U.N. soldiers were killed after some of the imams in the mosques there in Mazar-i-Sharif in Afghanistan remonstrated against Terry Jones who had burned the Koran, I don’t know, a week or two ago down there in Florida, and crowds went on a rampage and killed nine U.N. soldiers, wounded eleven others there in Mazar-i-Sharif, and these U.N. soldiers were from, well four of them were from Nepal. They wore burkas. One was a Swedish. Two of them were beheaded.

Of course, I got up on the ladder and I wanted to bring this—and this is what we do—I get up and take what’s on the news and I bring it around to the Gospel. I just got up there and said, ‘Listen, you all heard the news. You all heard what happened. What in the world went wrong, and why are you Muslims killing people for your Koran? Why in the world nine young men, or whatever their ages were, why did you kill nine men who had nothing to do with the burning of the Koran that took place thousands of miles away over in Florida by a pastor who did something he shouldn’t have done. Nonetheless, why do you kill people for doing this?’…

…Now, bringing that kind of thing at Speaker’s Corner brings a huge crowd, and I had a huge crowd yesterday. Hundreds were there, and the Muslims came all front and center, right in front of the ladder… And then I asked, ‘Should those men have been killed? Should those nine men have been killed, though they had nothing to do with the Koran? They didn’t even know Terry Jones. They are hundreds, thousands of miles away.’

And what was fascinating, Brian, as I said that, about six or seven Muslims started raising their fists and yelling, ‘Yes! Yes! Allahu-akbar! These men should be killed.’ So I said, ‘Do you all agree?’ All the Muslims, there may be about 40 or 50 Muslims there… ‘Do you all agree?’ And almost all of them said, yes, those men should be killed.

So I turned to the crowd. The crowd was huge, and you could see the horror on the faces of the crowd. It was priceless from where I was standing to look out and said, ‘Are you watching this? Are you looking at this? … Not even looking for the guilty party or if anybody is even guilty. Nonetheless, they would kill anybody. I said, ‘Why is it they should be killed?’ Because they weren’t Muslim.

Now that you can only do at Speaker’s Corner. You can only get that kind of reaction at Speaker’s Corner. And then you also can only get those kinds of crowds, and so we film it. We put that—that one, unfortunately, the fellow that does all the filming wasn’t there, so that didn’t get on film, although the same thing happened back in July when Terry Jones was going to do the same thing, and I did much the same kind of talk back in July. That got filmed and that’s up on YouTube. You can go and see it.

He can quite easily disprove any suspicion of dishonesty on his part by providing the footage seen as he claims he has this on video. The challenge has been set for him to provide the video footage. Smith, back in his days as a missionary in Africa, admitted he used a contextualisation method which does seem to be disingenuous although I understand he does not advocate or use these methods anymore. He tries to be more robust in his approach to Muslims nowadays. I trust Christians around him will want to encourage him to come forward and put this one to bed. Jonathan McLatchie and others who are close to Jay Smith, please look into this matter.

If it turns out to be the case, we have no qualms in rebuking and educating the Muslims in question. But it seems awfully suspicious that Jay does not have this footage uploaded.

Categories: Islam

1 reply

  1. Probably true if the Muslims in question belonged to the Anjem Choudry party.


Please leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: